Saturday, September 26, 2020
Home Recipe Reviews Beverages Grilled Cherry Milkshakes

Grilled Cherry Milkshakes

Whew! After those lightened up Cheeseburger Stuffed Shells, my first thought was to find a milkshake recipe. This Grilled Cherry Milkshakes recipe sounded like the perfect followup. Burgers and milkshakes are such a classic American combo, and I haven’t had a milkshake in ages. And, like those stuffed shells, this is a lightened up version of good old-fashioned comfort food. Plus I finally get to try grilled cherries. I have to admit I was a little disappointed when I didn’t get to grill them for the Whipped Ricotta Toast with Balsamic Cherries I made a while back. Not that they weren’t good, but grilled cherries!

Grilling a milkshake is kind of impossible. However, grilling the cherries you’re going to put in said milkshake is totally possible.

Recipe Author: Ashley at Edible Perspective
Get the recipe

The Ingredients

As you can see, there are only a few ingredients in this recipe. I had the vanilla extract and honey on hand. That left me to shop for the fresh cherries and both types of coconut milk (lite and regular). Not a terrible shopping list at all!

Grilled Cherry Milkshakes Ingredients
Bing cherries, full-fat coconut milk, light coconut milk, honey, and vanilla extract

The Process

Making these grilled cherry milkshakes wasn’t difficult, but it did take some planning. First, I had to buy an ice cube tray so I could freeze the full-fat coconut milk into cubes. Prepping them only took two minutes to do, including thoroughly mixing the coconut milk with an immersion blender. However, I had to wait overnight for the cubes to completely freeze.

I grilled the cherries the same day I prepped the coconut milk cubes because they also had to cool in the refrigerator. They took me 16 minutes to cut in half and pit, then another 10 minutes to grill on the stove. The recipe does say to use a grill pan on a grill heated to 375℉, but I don’t have an indoor grill. Instead, I kept my stove on medium-low, and I think I got good results. No charring, but also no burning.

The next day I mixed the frozen coconut milk ice cubes with the chilled light coconut milk in my food processor. I opted not to use my blender because the cubes were on the large side, and my food processor is more powerful than my blender. I didn’t have any trouble blending up two batches of coconut milk, and I put both into the freezer for an hour to firm up a bit.

Then I rinsed out my food processor and pureed the grilled cherries so they would be ready to go when the frozen coconut milk mixture was. I couldn’t wait! Actually making the milkshakes was the quickest and simplest part. All I had to do was divide the grilled cherry between two glasses, top with the frozen coconut milk mixture, and stir.

Grilling the cherries
Grilling the cherries

So how was it?

Clear & Accurate Directions
Accurate Time(s)
Grilling fresh cherries makes this milkshake a little extra, and I have never had anything like it. But even though it was incredibly good, it was a lot of work. There were multiple times when ingredients had to be frozen or chilled before I could continue with the recipe. As a result, I had to wait overnight for my milkshakes. Not to mention that I had to buy ice cube trays to freeze the coconut milk. I'm glad I tried this recipe as written, but next time I think I'll try it using vanilla ice cream as the author suggests (although I would opt for store-bought).
Hi, I'm Candice, and I'm The Hungry Pinner. I created this blog to share my love for cooking and my experiences with the MANY recipes I've found on Pinterest over the years. Be sure to check out my Pinterest boards and share your Pinterest cooking adventures in the comments section.


All comments are reviewed before they are posted and will not appear immediately.

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.


Apple Cranberry Bacon Kale Salad

This Apple Cranberry Bacon Kale Salad is quick, easy, healthy, and tasty, and I'm here for it! It combines a bunch of things I like into something I loved.

I'm social